- Insolvency Insider Australia
- Posts
- Victorian Court sets aside liquidator’s disclaimer of hazardous waste, rejecting attempt to shift $4.3 million liability to State
Victorian Court sets aside liquidator’s disclaimer of hazardous waste, rejecting attempt to shift $4.3 million liability to State
Supreme Court rules that prejudice to creditors under section 568B must be assessed collectively, finding that shifting the cost of disposing of more than 1 million litres of industrial waste to taxpayers would be grossly disproportionate to any benefit to creditors

The Supreme Court of Victoria has set aside a liquidator’s disclaimer of more than 1,000 containers of hazardous industrial waste, ruling that the disclaimer would expose the State of Victoria to a claim exceeding $4.3 million while providing virtually no benefit to creditors of the insolvent company. Justice Garde held that the statutory test for setting aside a disclaimer under section 568B of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) requires courts to compare the prejudice suffered by interested parties against the prejudice to the general body of creditors, rather than individual creditors or particular classes. The Court also found that environmental protection principles and the conduct of the parties favoured setting aside the disclaimer, rejecting an attempt by the operator of the storage facility to transfer responsibility for the waste to the State.
The dispute arose from the liquidation of Bradbury Industrial Services Pty Ltd, a Victorian waste management and recycling company that entered voluntary administration in July 2019 following a major fire at its Campbellfield facility. Several months before the fire, Bradbury had transferred 1,007 intermediate bulk containers holding approximately 1 million litres of flammable industrial waste, described as “Burner Fuel”, to a storage facility in Altona operated by Stolthaven Australia Pty Ltd.
In July 2019, ASCC Property Custodian Pty Ltd purchased the Altona premises, with its related company, Australasian Solvents and Chemical Company Pty Ltd (ASCC), taking over operations. The purchase agreement contained extensive environmental provisions under which ASCC Property accepted responsibility for contaminants at the property, including compliance with applicable environmental laws and regulatory notices.
Following Bradbury’s collapse, the companies became embroiled in a prolonged dispute over responsibility for the waste. The liquidator issued a disclaimer in December 2019 concerning Bradbury’s contractual arrangements relating to the premises. That disclaimer did not expressly cover the containers themselves.
After unsuccessful attempts to establish that the containers had already vested in the Crown as bona vacantia, ASCC sought a further disclaimer from Bradbury’s liquidator, Simon Thorn. On 15 February 2023, Thorn disclaimed the containers, following an agreement under which ASCC would provide an indemnity of up to $75,000 to Bradbury and the current and former liquidators.
The State promptly applied to set aside the disclaimer, arguing that its effect would be to transfer ownership of the waste to the Crown and expose it to substantial financial claims. ASCC subsequently removed and disposed of the containers between February and October 2023, engaging Geocycle SBF Pty Ltd to process much of the material for use as fuel in a cement kiln.
ASCC counterclaimed against the State for restitution exceeding $4.3 million, including GST, or alternatively compensation exceeding $1.3 million, relating to the storage, transport and disposal of the waste.
The central legal issue was the meaning of the expression “the company’s creditors” in section 568B(3), which permits a court to set aside a disclaimer only where the prejudice caused to persons with an interest, or claimed interest, in the property is grossly disproportionate to the prejudice that setting aside the disclaimer would cause to creditors.
Bradbury and the liquidator argued that the Court should consider prejudice to individual creditors and particular creditor classes, including ASCC. The State maintained that the provision required a comparison with creditors collectively.
Justice Garde accepted the State’s interpretation, finding that the statutory comparator was the general body of creditors. He also emphasised that prejudice to creditors must be assessed in their capacity as creditors of the insolvent company, rather than by reference to unrelated commercial or legal interests.
ASCC’s potential claims against the State arose from the consequences of the disclaimer, not from its position as a creditor of Bradbury, and therefore did not alter the statutory comparison.
The Court found that the disclaimer would expose the State to a substantial and actively pursued claim, while setting it aside would have virtually no effect on creditor recoveries. Even accounting for Bradbury’s disputed insurance claim against Allianz Australia, ordinary unsecured creditors were expected to receive no more than approximately five cents in the dollar, and potentially considerably less. The parties ultimately agreed that the insurance claim was immaterial to the statutory comparison.
Justice Garde also considered Victoria’s environmental protection legislation and the principles of shared responsibility and polluter pays. He attached significance to ASCC Property’s contractual assumption of environmental risks when acquiring the premises and rejected arguments that the conduct of environmental regulators justified leaving the disclaimer in place.
The Court concluded that the State’s potential exposure was grossly disproportionate to any prejudice suffered by creditors if the disclaimer were overturned. Justice Garde exercised his discretion to set aside the February 2023 disclaimer and dismissed ASCC’s counterclaim, which depended on the disclaimer remaining effective.
Mark Costello KC, Sarah Hogan and Alice Lloyd, instructed by Corrs Chambers Westgarth, represented the State of Victoria, the successful plaintiff and defendant by counterclaim.
Christopher Brown KC and Katherine Wangmann, instructed by Piper Alderman, represented Bradbury Industrial Services Pty Ltd (in liquidation) and its liquidator.
Stewart Maiden SC, Vicki Bell, Katie Gardiner and William Liu, instructed by Hope & Co, represented Australasian Solvents and Chemical Company Pty Ltd (ASCC) et al.